Decoding 'Carol': A Deep Dive into Love, Longing, and 1950s New York
Ever seen a movie that stays in your mind? Like a catchy song that you actually enjoy? For many, “Carol” is that film. Set during a snowy 1952 Christmas in New York City, it explores forbidden love, societal norms, and self-identity. “Carol” serves a different kind of warmth, simmering under the surface, like a good cup of cocoa on a chilly day.
Setting the Stage: Manhattan in the Merry (but not for everyone) '50s
Picture Christmas in 1952 Manhattan. Twinkling lights and department stores decked out for the holidays. Amidst the bustle is Therese Belivet, our main character, working at Frankenberg's department store. Therese's holiday spirit is dim. She is an aspiring photographer, feeling lost, like a black and white photo in a color world. Her gig? Selling dolls. Glamorous, right? In this visually rich setting, her life takes an unexpected turn. The film uses this Christmas atmosphere as a contrasting backdrop to characters' un-festive realities.
When Eyes Meet Across a Department Store Counter: Characters and Relationships
Meet Carol Aird. Glamorous, poised, and portrayed by Cate Blanchett with sophistication that could overshadow even Bond. Carol isn’t just buying a gift for her daughter; she seeks something deeper, maybe unconsciously. Their first meeting? Electric. Therese, the observant shop girl, and Carol, an elegant customer in a messy divorce. It's a classic meet-cute with a troubling age gap and societal disapproval.
Carol Aird: More Than Just a Glamorous Dame
Carol, oh Carol. Cate Blanchett embodies her character. This performance brings immersion. Carol suffers through a divorce, already scandalous for the '50s. She’s also drawn to women. Blanchett, at 46 during filming, adds a weariness and passion that captivates. She isn't just older than Therese; she carries societal expectations and personal sacrifices. This portrayal is nuanced and deserving of more awards. Seriously, Cannes.
Therese Belivet: Eyes Wide Open to a New World
Therese, played by Rooney Mara, serves as the audience's entry. She’s an aspiring photographer, an observer, seeing beyond surface details while figuring herself out. Her department store job isn’t her dream but it leads her to a life-changing encounter. Therese is young and naive. Her attraction to Carol is instant and intense, throwing her tightly controlled world into chaos. It's a sudden infatuation, amplified by the thrill of the unknown.
The Dance of Age and Desire: Relationship Dynamics
The age gap—sixteen years—between Carol and Therese is deliberate. It stems from Patricia Highsmith's novel, "The Price of Salt." Critics analyze this dynamic through the lens of mother-daughter relationships but it highlights power imbalances and societal norms of the time. Carol, worldly and experienced, guides Therese, unveiling new possibilities and perspectives. Imagine Carol handing Therese keys to a new car and saying, “Want to drive?”
Their relationship isn’t straightforward; it’s a dance of longing, fear, and societal pressure. Therese feels an "exciting feeling." Their initial day fades quickly, leaving Therese with unfulfilled desire. Carol’s complicated situation and societal condemnation mean Therese can’t voice her feelings openly. Though only about ten years older in the novel, Carol is portrayed as much more seasoned, amplifying the mentor-mentee connection evolving into something deeper.
Yet, not all is concerning imbalance. When Carol sees photos of Therese and says, “I never looked like that,” it humanizes her. It strips away the mythical image Therese has projected. It shows Therese that Carol isn't an untouchable goddess; she’s human and vulnerable, capable of insecurity. This vulnerability marks a significant turning point in their relationship.
In a crucial act of commitment, Carol proves the seriousness of her feelings for Therese. She makes a significant sacrifice, choosing Therese over her previous life, which risks custody of her daughter. This isn’t mere affection; it’s a transformative decision highlighting the depth of her love and the stakes of choosing love in an unaccepting world.
Themes Woven into the Winter Landscape
“Carol” isn’t just a love story; it’s a tapestry of themes woven into a beautiful yet isolating winter setting. The film guides us through romance, heartbreak, and longing—an emotional narrative wrapped in a visually stunning winter package.
The film also addresses the "struggle for dignity and autonomy against 1950s oppression." This involves not just two women falling in love. It explores defiance against societal norms. Choosing authenticity over conformity—even when conformity promises safety—is vital. Carol’s journey transcends mere romance and embraces personal liberation in a restrictive society.
Sacrifice appears as another main theme. Carol’s sacrifices include her feelings for others’ welfare. This reflects painful choices individuals face in oppressive conditions. Love can require sacrifice—not just of possessions but personal desires and societal standing. Carol acts to protect those she loves, often at her own emotional cost.
From Page to Screen: Adaptation and Source Material
Did you know “Carol” has true roots? It’s "based on Highsmith’s true experiences," primarily through her novel "The Price of Salt," published in 1952. The story chronicles Therese Belivet's dramatic life—a stage designer (switched to aspiring photographer) stuck in her department-store job. Highsmith’s experiences lend raw authenticity. A chance encounter with Carol shatters her routine, serving as a reminder that transformative moments often arise unexpectedly, like unanticipated gifts.
Critical Acclaim: More Than Just a Pretty Face
“Carol” shines not only visually but also critically. It’s a film where "surfaces" matter and beauty contrasts with the "dual nature of people and relationships." The aesthetic reflects the era and emotional undercurrents present. The British Film Institute named "Carol" the "best LGBT film of all time" in 2016, based on poll results from over one hundred film experts. This recognition underscores its lasting cultural and cinematic impact. The film resonates deeply beyond the LGBT community to anyone who has navigated love and identity complexities.
Emotional Resonance: Tears on the Train and Beyond
Recall the train scene where Therese cries? It's not random.
It is all melodrama. Therese's tears show "overwhelmed emotions" after a day of "strong connection with Carol." There is "frustration" over "Carol's marital complications." Therese feels limited. She feels "disappointed by her inability to offer Carol comfort." Confusion and longing surface on the train ride home. It shows the depth of human connection.
The Oscar Enigma: A Nod, but Not a Win
“Carol” had Oscar buzz but did not win. It received critical acclaim. However, no awards came its way. This does not lessen its achievement. It shows the unpredictability of awards season. Powerful films might not need trophies to show their worth. “Carol's” impact is emotional, not award-based.
Age is Just a Number? The Age Disparity Revisited
The age difference matters. "In the movie "Carol," Carol is about 16 years older than Therese." This is a key plot element that deepens their relationship. The age gap affects the dynamic of experience, mentor versus mentee, and societal views. Critics have noted Freudian angles, but the age difference shows their unconventional bond. It breaks societal norms and redefines love.
“Carol” is not just a film; it is an experience. It captures love amid constraints. It shows courage in living authentically. The deepest connections come from the unexpected places. If a film that leaves a mark is what you want, “Carol” belongs on your watchlist. Keep tissues handy for that train scene. Consider yourself warned.
Responses (0 )