Movie Outlines - Backstage, Briefs, Movie reviews and ratings by Film CriticDaily Dose Of Entertainment

Roger Ebert’s Top Films and the Art of Film Criticism: A Complete Guide

Roger Ebert: The Dean of American Film Criticism Roger Ebert was more than a critic; he was a cultural figure. He shaped how people viewed movies. From the Chicago Sun-Times to TV with Gene Siskel, Ebert’s influence was immense. His star ratings could lift or sink a film. He created discussions about cinema, welcoming everyone […]

Roger Ebert’s Top Films and the Art of Film Criticism: A Complete Guide

Roger Ebert: The Dean of American Film Criticism

Roger Ebert was more than a critic; he was a cultural figure. He shaped how people viewed movies. From the Chicago Sun-Times to TV with Gene Siskel, Ebert's influence was immense. His star ratings could lift or sink a film. He created discussions about cinema, welcoming everyone to join.

Decoding Ebert: Navigating the Star System and Beyond

When Roger Ebert comes to mind, stars appear, but not Hollywood ones. Ebert used a four-star system skillfully. Four stars meant cinematic brilliance. But what about the films with zero stars? Many ponder which ones fell into that abyss of despair.

The Pantheon of Perfection: Ebert's Four-Star Films

Ebert awarded four stars to a wide variety of films he cherished. This prestigious honor identified cinematic masterpieces that deeply resonated with him. His list from over five decades is vast, but certain films are discussed repeatedly. Titles like Raging Bull (1980) stand tall as transformative experiences. This Scorsese classic explores boxing and self-destruction and is available on Amazon Prime Video. Tokyo Story (1953) also captivates; Ozu's examination of family dynamics is on HBO Max. Then there’s The Tree of Life (2010); Malick’s artistic take on life can be found on Hulu. Hitchcock’s Vertigo (1958) offers thrilling mystery and is available for rental on Amazon Prime Video. These diverse masterpieces moved Ebert and left lasting impressions long after viewing.

The Abyss of Awfulness: Ebert's Zero-Star Films

Now, we delve into zero-star films. Ebert rarely gave zero stars; these films offended him deeply. In his expansive career from 1967 to 2013, such condemnation was rare but powerful. Notably, I Spit on Your Grave (1978) landed there, angering Ebert. Several other titles also earned this ignominious mark. Films like 10 to Midnight (1983), a slasher flick, and Africa: Blood and Guts (1966), a mondo film, joined that list. An Alan Smithee Film: Burn Hollywood Burn (1997) also qualified, a meta-comedy that was hilariously bad. Likewise, B*A*P*S (1997) struggled for laughs, and Caligula (1979) was infamously excessive. Ebert viewed these as cinematic sins against humanity.

Walk-Out Wonders: The Films Ebert Couldn't Endure

Besides star ratings, some films made Ebert walk out. He famously left several during his career, showcasing movies so intolerable they tested his limits. While the specifics vary, his walk-outs left a significant mark. Leaving a film is a profound statement, akin to a chef rejecting terrible food. It declared, "This is a waste of time and senses." Ebert rarely walked out, making it a notable event. Such disasters could shock a man whose career was built on film critique.

Ebert's Last Words on Film: A Final Positive Note

In his long career spanning decades, reflecting on Ebert's first and last reviews is intriguing. Identifying his first review is challenging, but the final one was To the Wonder (2012) by Terrence Malick. Coincidentally, Ebert’s last published critique was positive. There was no zero-star finale, but admiration for Malick's artistic style. This farewell resonates with his enduring love for cinema, lasting into his final days.

The Sheer Volume: Ebert's Herculean Movie Marathon

Let’s consider numbers. Roger Ebert evaluated at least 10,000 films. This figure is staggering—more than most will see in ten lifetimes. From 1967 to 2013, he worked tirelessly, producing reviews with passion. It reflects his unwavering love for film as an art form. He observed not merely movies; he chronicled cinematic history through his critiques. He functioned as a walking film database, insightful and witty.

Siskel & Ebert: A Tale of Two Godfathers (and Agreement!)

The dynamic of Roger Ebert and Gene Siskel was monumental. Their chemistry and debates became legendary, along with their "Two Thumbs Up" system. Yet even these critics found common ground. In 1972, both honored The Godfather as their film of the year independently. Imagine two critics with differing opinions acknowledging this film's brilliance. Their agreement highlights the movie's universal impact and importance in cinema history. Even in contrasts, they recognized greatness when they saw it.

Ebert's Inner Circle: His Pantheon of Favorite Films

While Ebert rated countless films, some resonated much more deeply with him. These movies were personal favorites, which he championed fiercely. We've noted some four-star films already, but let’s explore what truly connected with him.

Hitchcock's Notorious: The Pinnacle of Suspense

Ebert’s favorite Hitchcock film was Notorious (1946). He revered it as his top choice among Hitchcock's masterpieces. This film stands as a hallmark of suspense and romance. It features Cary Grant and Ingrid Bergman in a classic tale of intrigue. Ebert hailed its complex plot and characters, praising Hitchcock’s expert direction. In his opinion, Notorious epitomized Hitchcock's cinematic pinnacle; it represented everything he loved in cinema.

Beyond Notorious: A Spectrum of Cinematic Affection

While Notorious held a special place in Ebert's heart, his preferences spanned many genres.

Cinema reflects Ebert's diverse tastes. His favorites include Raging Bull, Tokyo Story, and The Tree of Life. These films formed a personal canon of excellence. They moved him deeply. Ebert loved these films. Exploring his favorites is a guided tour of cinema's history.

The Ebert Persona: More Than Just a Critic

Ebert was more than a critic. He was a cultural figure with a powerful voice. His writing and public persona allowed him to resonate beyond film. This will explore his life and career. Ebert is more than a reviewer; he is Roger Ebert.

The Midwestern Voice: Populism and Humanism in Prose

Ebert's writing was not academic. It was direct and engaging. His Midwestern style made complex ideas accessible. He valued films that touched audiences emotionally. Ebert wrote for movie lovers, not snobs. He demystified criticism, creating a public conversation.

Pulitzer Prize Pioneer: A Critic's Crowning Achievement

In 1975, Ebert won the Pulitzer Prize for Criticism. This marked a milestone in film criticism. It validated film criticism as journalism. Ebert's achievement brought respect and recognition. It paved the way for future critics.

A Decade-Long Battle: Ebert's Courage in the Face of Cancer

In 2002, Ebert faced thyroid cancer. This began a decade-long battle with health issues. Multiple surgeries included reconstructive surgery in 2006. He lost his ability to speak. Still, his written voice remained strong until his death in 2013. His struggle inspired many, symbolizing courage.

Final Curtain: Ebert's Poetic Last Words

Ebert passed away on April 4, 2013, at age 70. His death ended an era in film criticism. Chaz Ebert shared his last words: a quote from Macbeth. These words reflect a deep perspective on life. Perhaps Ebert was contemplating existence and the power of stories.

From Academia to the Arts: Ebert's Path to Criticism

Ebert's path to film criticism was unique. He earned a journalism degree in Illinois, then pursued a Ph.D. in English. However, he chose writing full-time, abandoning academia. His academic background shaped his criticism, bridging scholarly rigor with public accessibility.

No Children, Just Cinema: Ebert's Personal Life

Ebert was married to Chaz Hammelsmith from 1992 to 2013. They shared a loving bond. Chaz supported him during his health struggles. They had no children. His family was cinema, and his legacy continues through his work and influence.

Graceland Chapel, Cremated Remains: The Afterlife of a Critic

After passing, Ebert's memorial service took place at Graceland Chapel in Chicago. However, his crematory had closed before then. Ebert's ashes were likely with Chaz. Graceland Chapel was a fitting choice due to its beauty and significance.

Siskel and Ebert: Friendly Rivals, Lasting Bond

The relationship between Siskel and Ebert was complex. They weren't best friends but shared a close bond. Their debates were legendary. Beneath rivalry, they respected each other's opinions. After Siskel's death in 1999, Ebert honored their bond and legacy.

The Everlasting Debate: What is the "Best Movie of All Time"?

The search for the best movie sparks endless debates. Is there a single answer? Not really. Film tastes vary based on experiences and preferences. What resonates with one viewer may not affect another. However, some films appear consistently in discussions of greatness.

No Single Answer: The Subjectivity of Cinematic Greatness

There is no consensus on the best movie ever. What makes a film "best" is subjective. Different viewers focus on different elements: innovation, impact, significance, or success. A film may be a masterpiece to one but overrated to another. This diversity lies at the heart of cinema's beauty.

The Usual Suspects: Films Frequently in the "Best Of" Conversation

Some films frequently appear in "best of" discussions. Titles like The Godfather, The Dark Knight, The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King, and 2001: A Space Odyssey are contenders for the cinematic crown. These films leave lasting impacts and inspire future filmmakers.

Citizen Kane

: A Perennial Poll Topper

Orson Welles's Citizen Kane (1941) remains a top film. It dominates many "best of" lists. This film shines in international polls, like the British Film Institute's Sight and Sound. It held a number one spot for fifty years. It showcases unique storytelling and impressive cinematography. The film explores themes of power and ambition. Citizen Kane is a pivotal work in cinema.

Five-Star Favorites: A Glimpse at Highly Rated Gems

Besides the "best" discussions, many movies achieved acclaim. Think about films like The Shawshank Redemption (1994), Spirited Away (2001), The Sting (1973), and The Terminator (1984). These films span genres and years, achieving excellence. Each gained accolades and a loyal fan base. They show cinematic artistry's range. Greatness appears in diverse forms.

Behind the Silver Screen: Intriguing Movie Industry Facts

The movie industry combines glamour and surprising realities. Beyond the red carpets, intriguing facts exist. These details reveal Hollywood's inner workings. Let's explore some movie industry trivia.

Rotten Tomatoes Royalty: The Perfect Score of Leave No Trace

Rotten Tomatoes, the review aggregation site, highlights positive reviews with its Tomatometer. Many films aim for high scores, but Leave No Trace (2018) stands uniquely high. It enjoys a rare perfect score of 100%, based on 253 optimistic reviews. This success signifies universal acclaim. Leave No Trace showcases independent cinema's strength.

Box Office Bomb: The Curious Case of Zyzzyx Road

As Avatar reaches box office highs, Zyzzyx Road (2006) takes the lowest spot. This thriller made only $30 at box offices. It barely registered on the radar. Reasons for its failure are debated, but it highlights that not all Hollywood films succeed.

Williams' Star Wars Score: A Symphony of Success

John Williams's score for Star Wars (1977) is iconic. The music influences the film's impact significantly. Williams’s work elevates this space opera to cultural heights. The score is recognizable and ingrained in popular culture.

Star Wars Mania: A Galaxy of References

Star Wars influences popular culture extensively. It has over 6100 references in various media. Its presence is felt in movies, TV shows, and books. This lasting influence demonstrates its popularity.

Eric Roberts: The Prolific King of Quantity (and Maybe Quality?)

Some actors choose selective roles, unlike Eric Roberts. This prolific actor appears in over 300 films, the highest number for any actor. His output rivals that of industrious filmmakers. While quality varies, his dedication to acting is clear.

Avatar's Reign: The King of the Box Office Mountain

Avatar (2009) sits on top of box office history. James Cameron's visually stunning film has earned $2.847 billion globally. Its success is due to impressive visual effects and broad appeal. This achievement redefined box office records.

Decoding Movie Ratings: A Starry and Lettered Guide

Movie ratings guide audiences on quality and content. Understanding different systems helps navigate cinema better. Let’s explore the world of ratings, from stars to letters.

Common Sense Media: A Family-Friendly Star System

Common Sense Media rates movies based on family content. Their five-star system differs from Ebert's. Three stars mean "Just fine; solid," indicating a decent film. Ratings lower than 3 stars are disappointing at best. Their system assists parents in making viewing choices.

The Elusive 10-Star Movie: Hyperbole or True Masterpiece?

"10-star movies" wow audiences without following strict rating guidelines. Ebert capped at 4 stars. Yet some systems use a 10-star scale. Films like The Shawshank Redemption, The Godfather, and others appear frequently. These ratings often reflect enthusiasm more than critical standards.

Rotten Tomatoes' Top 300: A Critic-Approved Canon

Rotten Tomatoes lists the 300 best movies based on critical reviews. This selection represents cinematic excellence. Films like L.A. Confidential, The Godfather, and others belong on this list. It provides insight into critically acclaimed films spanning genres.

AFI's 100 Years...100 Movies: American Cinematic Landmarks

The American Film Institute's lists spotlight key films that shaped cinema. These periodic lists recognize cultural impact and artistic achievements. Many films overlap with Rotten Tomatoes' best films, emphasizing their importance in film history.

The Origin of Stars: Mobil's Guide to Quality

The star rating system began with the Mobil Travel Guide in 1958. Mobil funded anonymous reviews for restaurants and hotels. This method led to the five-star system used today in various reviews, including film critique.

NC-17: Adults Only, No Exceptions

The NC-17 rating stands as the most restrictive category in film ratings. It indicates "No Children Under 17 Admitted." This rating is strictly for adults, with no exceptions for younger viewers, even with parental guidance. It's reserved for films with explicit content.

Extra Reel: Bonus Cinematic Trivia

M
WRITTEN BY

Mark Yun

Responses (0 )